A Few Good Men Broadway Review When âA Few Good Menâ debuted on Broadway in 1989, this courtroom drama about the defense of two Marines charged with murdering a fellow soldier, was viewed as the latest in a long line of similarly conventional genre plays and movies; one critic labeled it a âyuppie version of âThe Caine Mutiny Court-Martial.ââ But this was the breakthrough show for its author, Aaron Sorkin, who has become a one-man brand. So now itâs seen as the very first in a long line of Aaron Sorkin Productions, which include âThe West Wingâ on TV, âThe Social Networkâ on film, and his adaptation of âTo Kill a Mockingbirdâ on stage. Sorkinâs brand prominence is surely the truest explanation for why this play, although often portentous and glib, and long overshadowed by the later blockbuster movie version, is getting a monumentally staged, occasionally riveting, but ultimately unmemorable Broadway revival. It opened tonight at Lincoln Centerâs Vivian Beaumont Theater, starring Tom Blyth as the reluctant crusading lawyer, Krysta Rodriguez as his relentless goad, and Bradley Whitford as his nemesis. A legend has grown around Sorkin and his big break. He was working as a bartender in the Palace Theater during its run of âLa Cage Aux Follesâ when he had a telephone conversation with his sister Deborah, a lawyer with the U.S. Navy Judge Advocate Generalâs Corps, about her latest case, the defense of a Marine who was a part of a group charged with hazing a fellow soldier on orders of a superior officer at the U.S. naval base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. He started writing up the story on cocktail napkins at the theater bar, and then typing up his scrawls on an early Apple Computer, the Macintosh 512k, when he got back to his cramped studio apartment, which he shared in a complicated arrangement with two roommates. The resulting play, his Broadway playwriting debut at age 28, ran for a respectable 14 months, and led to the 1992 movie, his Hollywood screenwriting debut. Directed by Rob Reiner, the movie featured indelible performances by Tom Cruise, Demi Moore, and Jack Nicholson, who immortalized the line: âYou canât handle the truth.â It was nominated for four Academy Awards, and made $243 million on a budget of $40 million. Aaron Sorkin never had to bartend again. The problem with the legendary success of the movie (which is currently available on various streaming platforms), as well as Sorkinâs many subsequent successes, is that they set up expectations for a stage revival of this early work. There can be pleasure in Sorkinâs signature rapid-fire witty exchanges, but some of the dialogue is problematic, the worst of it at the expense of the female character. There is a visual majesty to the staging, but its massive cast in starched military uniforms sometimes feel swallowed up in Dane Laffreyâs imposing, tower-high set on the cavernous stage of the Vivian Beaumont, flanked by industrial-sized flags of the United States of America and the United States Marine Corps. They are apparently going for patriotic here, but it was hard to take in the overwhelming scale, the stark pillars and the harsh lighting and not think of fascist architecture. Like any courtroom drama or procedural, the story is easy to get caught up in, but there are problems here too. Tom Blyth, a screen actor best known for his starring role in the fifth Hunger Games movie, is making his Broadway debut as Lieutenant Junior Grade Daniel Kaffee, a Harvard Law School graduate who has served in the Judge Advocate Generalâs Corps for only nine months, and would rather be playing softball. Easy-going and popular, he is admired for the speed with which he turns all his cases into plea bargains. He is assigned the defense of the two marines who beat up another soldier, resulting in his death, with the expectation that this will be just another plea bargain. Instead, he pursues it through the ups and downs of the case. In the process, weâre meant to see that he first admits his i (he had a successful father who died young, who he fears he canât measure up to) and then finally takes his job seriously. He accomplishes this at the urging of Lieutenant Commander Joanne Galloway (portrayed by Krysta Rodriguez), who feels passionate from the start that the two young marines were not acting on their own. She suspects they were following orders to commit a âCode Red,â an informal disciplinary action for marines who fail to measure up. Pfc William Santiagoâs infractions included an inability to complete a run without collapsing; he also went outside the chain of command to write letters requesting that he be transferred. Joanne pushed unsuccessfully to be assigned to defend the men with the officer who does the assigning, Capt. Isaac Whitaker (Billy Eugene Jones), in one of the most cringe-worthy exchanges of the play, if not of Sorkinâs career. âDo you always talk as if your dialogue was written by someone whoâs not very good at it?â Whitaker asks her a few lines in. âIâm sorry if my over-eagerness is grating,â she replies. âItâs not, itâs endearing. You could have a career as a cartoon squirrel.â Joanne as annoying is a constant motif in the play (far more than in the movie), making her the butt of many jokes.. Nick Blaemire as Lt. Sam Weinberg is the third lawyer on the team, Dannyâs buddy, a good sounding board and a wit, if comically hapless. The three go up against Lieutenant Colonel Nathan R. Jessep, the commander whom Joanne suspects of ordering the Code Red and then covering it up. Danny surmises that the hard-nosed officer sees his team as â the pushy broad, the smart Jew, and the Harvard mouth.â It strikes me as difficult for the audience to see them as much more complex than that either, in part because of the way the characters are written, but also (with the exception of Blaemire) the way they are performed. Colonel Jessep, the villain of the story, is portrayed by Bradley Whitford. Thirty-six years ago, in his Broadway debut, Whitford portrayed Danny (understudy and then replacement) in the original production. He seems better suited for a drily witty regular guy than a fearsome, humorless martinet, but itâs possible my view is colored by the seven seasons I spent watching him as Josh Lyman in âThe West Wing.aâ Michael Arden, the Tony-winning director who has had Broadway success with such disparate shows as âParade,â âHappy Ending,â and âThe Lost Boys,â has told interviewers that he wanted to mount âA Few Good Menâ because it speaks to the present day. He cited the video made by Six Democratic lawmakers, all veterans of the military and the intelligence services, telling current members of the military that they can and should refuse illegal orders. There is one passage in the play that brings up the Nazis in Nuremberg in passing. But I just donât see the play as effectively addressing this issue â itâs too bogged down in the details of the specific case. If anything, itâs Colonel Jessep who makes the most direct and persuasive argument â that there is no such thing as an illegal order, when lives are at stake. âWe use words like honor, code, loyalty. We use these words as the backbone to a life spent defending something. You use them as a punchline.â A Few Good Men Vivian Beaumont Theater through January 10, 2027 Running time: 2 hours and 35 minutes, including one 15-minute intermission. Tickets: $114 â $421 Written by Aaron Sorkin Directed by Michael Arden Scenic design by Dane Laffrey; costume design by Alejo Vietti; lighting design by Japhy Weideman; sound design by Joshua D. Reid; hair and wig design by Cookie Jordan; make-up design by Kirk Cambridge-Del Pesche Cast: Bradley Whitford as LtCol Nathan R. Jessep, Tom Blyth as LTJG Daniel Kaffee, Krysta Rodriguez as LCDR Joanne Galloway, Stephanie Berry as âJudge Randolph,â Nick Blaemire as âLt. Sam Weinberg,â Michael Braugher as âCpl. Jeffrey Howard,â Christopher Gurr as âDr. Stone,â Billy Eugene Jones as âCapt. Isaac Whitaker,â Collin Kelly-Sordelet as âPfc. Louden Downey,â ShuntĂ© Lofton as âSentry/Orderly,â Michael Oberholtzer as âCapt. Jack Ross,â Lavel Schley as âLance Cpl. Harold W. Dawson,â Thom Sesma as âCapt. Matthew Markinson,â Daniel Velez as âPfc William Santiago,â John Zdrojeski as âLt. Jonathan Kendrick,â with Brendan Evan Behm, Alex Ekker, Drew Elhamalawy, Miles Fowler, Quentin Nguyen-duy, and Stephen Michael Spencer as âMarine/Military Personnel,â Understudies: Peter Bradbury, Tim Creavin, Mahira Kakkar, and Austin Phillips https://newyorktheater.me/2026/10/29/a-few-good-men-broadway-review/ #fewgood #goodmen #aaronsorkin #sorkinproductions #vivianbeaumont #cainemutiny #socialnetwork #westwing #beaumonttheater #tomblyth #rss #feeds #linksharing #qwibbit